If I asked whether lapsed every donor matters, I hope we’d all answer the same way.
“Of course.”
Whether someone gave $5 or $5,000, they believed in your mission enough to support it. Every gift matters, every donor deserves to be appreciated, and every person who raises their hand to say, “I want to help,” should be treated with gratitude.
But somewhere along the way, I think we’ve accidentally blurred the line between valuing every donor and treating every donor exactly the same. Those aren’t the same thing, and when we’re talking about lapsed donors, confusing those two ideas can get expensive.
So what does this mean?
Let’s say your Executive Director comes into your office and says there’s enough room in the budget for a lapsed donor impact this year.
Great news.
Until someone asks the next question.
“Who will we send it to?”
Your first instinct might be, “All of them,” which I completely understand. It’s fair. It’s donor-centered. It feels like the right answer.
The problem is, very few (if any) nonprofits have unlimited budget, unlimited staff, or unlimited time. Every organization has to make choices, whether they want to or not. The question isn’t whether you’ll prioritize.
The question is whether you’ll prioritize intentionally or accidentally.
Here’s another hypothetical:
I give you $10,000 and tell you that you can only spend it reactivating one of two groups of donors.
The first group gave $500 or more, and their last gift was about 18 months ago.
The second group gave around $25, and their last gift was five years ago.
Which group are you choosing?
If you’re like most fundraisers, you probably answered that question in about two seconds. The second group matters, but that first group represents a much stronger opportunity. That’s what prioritization is. It’s not deciding which donors are valuable as people.
It’s deciding where your limited resources are most likely to make the biggest difference.
Ironically, I don’t think the biggest mistake organizations make is ignoring those higher-opportunity donors.
It’s that they spend their finite budget on everyone else, too.
Maybe they export everyone who hasn’t given in the last three years and send them all the same appeal. Maybe that team doesn’t know how to separate stronger opportunities from weaker ones inside their CRM. Maybe they simply don’t have the time to dig into the data because they’re busy writing appeals, planning events, meeting with donors, and doing the hundred other things fundraisers juggle every week.
None of those are unreasonable problems.
But they do create an unreasonable outcome.
The donors most likely to come back end up mixed in with thousands of others, and everyone receives the same amount of attention simply because it’s easier than figuring out who should receive more.
I hear another concern pretty regularly.
“What if that $10 donor is secretly our next major donor?”
Could that happen?
Absolutely.
But people can also win the lottery. That doesn’t mean spending your paycheck on Powerball tickets is a sound retirement strategy.
Good fundraising isn’t built around exceptions.
It’s built around probabilities. We make the best decisions we can with the information we have today, not the information we hope to have tomorrow. If someone gave you $5 once six years ago, could they eventually become a donor with the capacity to transform your organization?
Sure.
But if someone gave you $500 every year for the last five years and quietly stopped giving 16 months ago, I know which conversation I’m having first.
That doesn’t mean the first donor doesn’t matter.
It just means they aren’t my first priority.
Here’s something practical you can do this week:
Pull a list of your lapsed donors and their giving history.
Don’t write a campaign yet. Don’t start brainstorming clever subject lines or direct mail packages.
Just look at the list.
Specifically, look at two things:
- What’s the largest gift each donor has made?
- How recently did they give it?
That’s it.
You don’t need a fancy dashboard or an expensive analytics platform to learn something useful. Just spending thirty minutes with that list will probably change how you think about your donor file. You’ll notice people you forgot about. You’ll find donors who gave faithfully for years before quietly disappearing. And you’ll probably discover that some of the donors you planned to spend money trying to reactivate aren’t nearly as strong an opportunity as others.
Now, does that mean those donors should never hear from you again?
Of course not. Every donor still matters.
What we’re talking about isn’t whether someone deserves your appreciation. It’s whether they deserve to be first in line when your budget only allows you to do so much. Those are two very different questions.
One last thought, while I have you here.
I think nonprofits spend a lot of time trying to figure out why donors lapsed. Sometimes that’s helpful. Sometimes it isn’t.
People move.
People retire.
People lose jobs.
People have kids.
People get sick.
Sometimes donors stop giving because of something your organization did. Sometimes they stop giving because life happened.
It isn’t always your fault that someone lapsed.
But it is your responsibility to decide what happens next.
The good news is that making that decision gets a whole lot easier when you know which donors deserve your attention first.
Want a second set of eyes on your donor file?
One of the things Oneicity does through Donor ReBond is help nonprofits identify which lapsed donors represent the strongest opportunities for reactivation. We look at your donor file, help quantify the opportunity, and build a practical plan for reconnecting with the people most likely to come back.
If you’ve ever looked at your donor database and wondered, “Where do I even start?” we’d love to help.
Photo by Brett Jordan on Unsplash

